• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Joint Public Issues Team

Churches working for peace and justice

  • Home Page
  • Who We Are
    • Six hopes for society
  • Issues
    • Economy
      • Tax Justice
      • Reset The Debt
      • Living Wage
    • Environment
      • Net Zero In My Neighbourhood
    • Poverty and Inequality
      • The Cost of Living Crisis
      • Universal Credit
      • Truth and Lies
      • Enough
      • Rethink Sanctions
      • Faith in Foodbanks
      • Housing and Homelessness
    • Asylum and Migration
      • Refugees
      • End Hostility
      • The Asylum System
    • Peacemaking
      • The Arms Trade
      • Nuclear Weapons
      • Drones
      • Peacemaking resources
    • Politics and Elections
      • Elections
      • Meet Your MP
      • Art of the Possible
      • Brexit
    • Other Issues
      • International Development
      • Modern Slavery and Exploitation
        • Forced labour in fashion
  • Get Involved
    • JPIT Conference 2022
    • Newsletter
    • Events
    • Walking with Micah
  • Resources
    • Advent
    • 10 Minutes on… podcast
    • Politics in the Pulpit?
    • Stay and Pray
    • Season of Creation
    • Prayers
    • Public Issues Calendar
    • Poetry
    • Small Group Resources
  • Blog

Philpott: Twisting one story to tar a whole section of our society.

Blog, Poverty and Inequality · 3 April, 2013

The report “The lies we tell ourselves” includes the following paragraph

“It is always possible to find examples of individual good or bad behaviour, including by people living in poverty. It is also possible to use a story of this example to justify an opinion. However we should not attempt to understand a large group of people on the basis of a single story, rather than on the evidence.”

This morning’s Daily Mail coverage of the awful Philpot case does just that. It uses the example of Philpott, someone convicted of killing five of his own children, to attack the entire welfare system and those who use it. The system encompasses well over 9 million people, but this morning one person has been chosen to represent them – a less representative representative would be hard to find, but I am sure they will one day.

Let me be clear Philpott is no more representative of those on welfare than Shipman was representative of GPs. Because we know and value GPs in our communities it would not have crossed anyone’s mind to name Shipman as typical of the healthcare system. It is telling (not to mention worrying) that a newspaper editor believes that Philpott will be a popular example of benefit claimants to the general public. What’s even more worrying is that he might be correct.

The reason the Churches gathered together to write the Truth and Lies report is that the stories of the poorest were being told by people who could use them to suit their own purposes – and the poorest were being grossly misrepresented as a result. Stories are much more powerful at conveying a message than statistics are, but when drawing conclusions about a group of millions of people an understanding of the numbers is nevertheless essential. In the report we highlighted how unrepresentative some of the most commonly chosen stories about the poorest are, and that statistics have been continually used in a misleading way. Today’s story is a new low, but the process is the same old routine.

The stories that represent the poorest communities in our country are not being chosen by the poorest themselves – they are chosen by politicians and media who have their own objectives – politicians and media increasingly drawn from privileged backgrounds, removed from the places were poverty most commonly resides. Yesterday the chancellor talked of families receiving £100,000 a year in housing benefit – much less tasteless – but if you read the report you’ll find it is no more representative – literally a one in a million case.

Initiatives such as the Glasgow Poverty Truth Commission allow people from disadvantaged communities to tell their own story in their own way to people in power. They are a beacon of hope against a background of negative stories and slander. It is not easy hope – Martin Johnstone, a Church of Scotland minister and the secretary of the Commission, writes of the moving and sometimes disturbing testimony given here – but a genuine hope. The people giving testimony are clearly the real poverty experts, people of value, dignity and worth, who deserve their place at the decision-making table – not out of sympathy or charity but because of the simple truth that policies developed without their stories at the heart will be unjust and will simply fail.

Filed Under: Blog, Poverty and Inequality

Paul Morrison

I am the policy advisor with particular responsibility for issues around the economy including poverty and inequality. Prior to working for the Methodist Church I was a postdoctoral researcher at Imperial College studying viral disease and vaccine design.

Previous Post: « More nonsense about the cost of welfare – and why it is a myth that never dies.
Next Post: DWP’s cleverly worded truth, leads to very many lies »

Primary Sidebar

Search

Recent Posts

  • JPIT’s Review of 2022
  • What does Government Support for Asylum Seekers really provide?
  • God with Us – the Refugees of Calais and Dunkirk
  • How can we respond to COP27?
  • Statement on the conclusion of the COP27 Climate Conference in Sharm el-Sheikh, Egypt
  • COP27 – what should we be looking for?
  • “He has filled the hungry with good things” – What we need from the Autumn Budget
  • What are the stories we should tell about the humanitarian crisis at Manston Airport Asylum centre?
  • How can we be sure that the products we buy are not the result of modern slavery?
  • Why I hate Warm Banks (and why my church is opening one)
  • How does our theology call us to challenge Poverty?
  • Introducing Alfie
  • Biden says nuclear risk is the highest since the 1962 Cuban Missile Crisis
  • Churches respond to risk to benefit levels
  • Briefing on the ‘Mini Budget’ for the Enough to Live group
  • Introducing Hazel
  • Introducing Hannah
  • An energy cap announcement in three parts: the good, the absent and the ugly
  • Afghanistan and the UK – One Year On from the Fall Of Kabul
  • Inflation, interest rates and the poorest

Subscribe to our monthly newsletter

Footer

Follow us

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Quick links

Stay and Pray
Politics in the Pulpit
Faith in Politics podcast
Public Issues Calendar
Useful Links

Our work

About Us
Meet the Team
Join the Team 
Internship
Our Newsletter

Contact us

25 Marylebone Road
London NW1 5JR

Tel: 020 7916 8632

enquiries@jpit.uk

Copyright © 2023 · Showcase Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in